Skip to content

Screener Squad: The Muppets Mayhem

The Muppets Mayhem Review


It’s time to play the music. It’s time to light the lights. It’s time to meet the rock band that debuted back in 1975 on a sketch comedy show called The Muppet Show. After the series finale of The Muppet Show back in 1981, Doctor Teeth and the Electric Mayhem went on tour and have never stopped rocking all around the world. Dr. Gerald Teeth Jr (Bill Barretta) the lead singer and keyboardist, Animal (Eric Jacobson) on the drums, Floyd Pepper (Matt Vogel) slap’n the bass while providing backup vocals, Janice (David Rudman) wailing on the guitar, Zoot (Dave Goelz) breathing fire into the brass belly of a saxophone, and Lips (Peter Linz) on the trumpet. Over 4 decades of playing together without a single album to show for it. Nora Singh (Lilly Singh) is a driven music exec who persuades the band to stop the party bus and put those notes to vinyl. She believes the band has a platinum record in them and for the record she’s not alone in her quest. Her social media influencer sister Hannah (Saara Chaudry) and number one super fan Moog (Tahj Mowry) will team up to spread the love, joy, laughter, and wisdom of The Muppets. Bradly gathers a choir of felt fanatics in Dogget, Tessa, and Rae, to compose a critical orchestra of thought provoking laughter. They’ll discuss whether or not yet another attempt at rebooting the Muppets is worth it, if the musical stylings of the almost half century old band can still inspire, and if cameos are even noticeable when going toe to toe with Muppets.


CREATED BY: Adam F. Goldberg, Bill Barretta, and Jeff Yorkes

STARRING: Lilly Singh, Bill Barretta, Leslie Carrara-Rudolph, Dave Goelz, Eric Jacobson, Peter Linz, David Rudman, Matt Vogel, Saara Chaudry, Tahj Mowry, Anders Holm, Stephanie D’Abruzzo, David Bizzaro, Jordan Brownlee, Alice Dinnean, Bradley Freeman Jr., Donna Kimball, Tim Lagasse, Bruce Lanoil, Drew Massey, Sarah Sarang Oh, Michael Oosterom, Nicolette Santino, Stoph Scheer, Michelan Sisti, Art Vega, Alex Villa, Paula Abdul, Steve Aoki, Rachel Bloom, Karamo Brown, Nicole Byer, Sofia Carson, Charlamagne The God, Tommy Chong, Billy Corgan, deadmau5, Desiigner, Colton Dunn, Morgan Freeman, Susanna Hoffs, James Hong, Jennifer Irwin, Peter Jackson, Kesha, Tommy Lee, Lil Nas X, Riki Lindhome, Cheech Marin, Ziggy Marley, Jack McBrayer, Arden Myrin, Nico Santos, Kristen Schaal, Ben Schwartz, Ryan Seacrest, Kevin Smith, Chris Stapleton, Danny Trejo, Joe Lo Truglio, “Weird Al” Yankovic, Cedric Yarbrough, Zedd




Bradly Martin (Screener Squad, Eye on the Prize, Breakfast Pub)

Bradly Martin was born in the united states and grew up on a healthy diet of sports, films, and books. A rather shy lad who kept to himself, Bradly soon discovered the best way to know a person was to know what people liked. Throughout the years Bradly became a fan of many things and a fanatic of none. From Doctor Dre, to Doctor Strange and the who’s who of Whos. From Playstation to the Dreamcast and Marvel to DC. From LeBron James to James Bond and Lord of the Rings to Lord Palmerston (or Pitt the Elder if you agree with Wade Boggs) and is a huge fan of dad jokes and randomly obscure Simpsons references. Armed with a vast knowledge of comics, films, and pop culture. Bradly traveled the world making friends and sharing takes. As a young man Bradly married the love of his life young and grew older every year with each new child brought into the brood. If trends continue, Scientists predict that .2% of Canada (where Bradly and family reside) will be populated by Bradly’s children by the year 2029. You can hear him leading and listening to his favorite critics on the Screener Squad and Eye on the prize and maybe even provide some comments of his own.



Danny Dogget (Screener Squad)

Hey persons, it’s your favorite canine Dogget! As many of you know, I don’t identify as a critic as much as a classy shock jock. That being said, I do my best to give all of you a well-balanced review filled with my true opinions and hopefully a few laughs. You can occasionally find me on other persons podcast like Mission Impodible (that’ll be 10 dollars Nathan). For the most part, you can find me doing reviews on



Tessa Morrison (Highly Suspect Reviews, Screener Squad, Unstabletop Gamers)

Well-rounded nerd and artist, Tessa Morrison grew up in the misty mountains of West Virginia and was constantly ridiculed for being a “weirdo.” Then moved to Austin in 2009 where people said the same thing, but in an endearing tone. Tessa works an office day job, creates puppets and fiber art, cosplays, models for gaming and animation studios, and volunteers for various organizations. One of which is the Other Worlds Film Festival, Austin’s first SciFi film fest, working in the capacity of Outreach Director and programmer. Another is local DIY-comedy-wrestling league, Party World Rasslin’, where Tessa scrambles around stage-handing and doing art department nonsense. Wrote and contributed to website and magazine Strange Kids Club for five years reviewing films, video games, and Halloween candy. Co-hosted a Public Access show called Ladies of Fandom. Previously guested on podcasts Blood Over Texas, Threequel Club, Trash in the Can, Retro Movie Roundtable, and Nerds with Mics.



Lyrae Anderson (Screener Squad)

You can call me Rae. You can also call me a film lover. I’ll watch it all — small screen; big screen, and everything in between. I have attended and worked for Fantastic Fest and South by Southwest for many years. I married a film geek as well. While we don’t agree on everything, we agree on our love of movies.



You can subscribe to the Highly Suspect Reviews and Screener Squad series of podcasts on iTunes, Spotify, and more, or use our RSS feed on whatever podcast service you use: and please leave us a review!

Please think about becoming a paid subscriber to, support our huge network of shows, and get access to tons of bonus shows and videos in our forums! We cannot keep this site going without support from our listeners. For added information about being a subscriber, the benefits, and the forums, please go here.

Subscription Levels
Red Shirt : $2.00 USD – monthly
Brown Coat : $5.00 USD – monthly
Time Lord : $10.00 USD – monthly
Jedi : $25.00 USD – monthly

Dollicious Ad 2022

Dead Friends Society Ad


Knomad ad

Outside In Trusts No One