We Are Error Reviews: Batman Ep. 4: Guardian of Gotham | One of Us

We Are Error Reviews: Batman Ep. 4: Guardian of Gotham

3 Submitted by on Mon, 12 December 2016, 17:59

Chris and Jon are joined yet again by OneOfUs.net contributor Justin Zarian to review TellTale Games’s latest entry in their episodic Batman series. Along with talking about what they liked and didn’t like about Guardian of Gotham, the trio have a spoiler heavy discussion on the choices they made as Gotham’s Caped Crusader.

Be sure to check out our reviews for the first three episodes, Realm of Shadows, Children of Arkham and New World Order.


You can also follow us on Twitter at @weareerrorcast!

Interested in purchasing some of the games mentioned in the review? Please use our Amazon links to do so! Every purchase allows us to produce even more content for you. Thanks!

batman_telltale_ps4            batman_telltale_xbox


Find tickets and showtimes on Fandango.

General- Sideshow Collectibles

Subscribe to One of Us Audible Trial

Written by

While braving the snow-swept wasteland of Buffalo, New York for 18 long years, Christopher Herman developed a love for geek culture. A child of the 90s, he was raised on the valuable lessons taught by Batman: The Animated Series, Hey Arnold and Animaniacs. Eventually discovering a passion for movies, books, comics and video games, Chris began hoarding his knowledge of geekdom. Whether it’s Star Wars, The Lord of the Rings, Mass Effect, Firefly or Avatar: The Last Airbender, he’s always willing to discuss the intricate worlds and stories of geek properties. Chris currently resides in San Marcos, TX.
  • 我只是来看一看,好久没来了~

  • Jonathan Snyder

    I enjoyed episode 4, not as much as the other episodes but i thought it was decent. I thought the Joker was okay in this episode, he was certainly a better Joker than Jared Leto.

    I also played the finale today. and despite a few technical hiccups, I thought it was pretty good. I won’t go into detail for the sake of spoilers, but i will say that they do have a simple yet legit reason as for Catwoman’s departure in episode 4 in the finale.

    Overall I’d give this season an 8.5 out of 10. Despite the technical issues and a few weak points in the writing, this was a unique and memorable Batman story and game, that surpassed my expectations and I am glad I got a chance to play it.

    As for my choices in episode 4:

    Stopped the fight and saved the guard
    Ran the barricade
    Went to Harvey as Batman
    Went to Wayne Tech to stop Oz.

    • I was happy to see that this was a story about Bruce Wayne and not Batman. Very different from what we’re used to seeing in most Batman stories.