The formula for an Oscar nomination, now backed with data | One of Us

The formula for an Oscar nomination, now backed with data

4 Submitted by on Thu, 16 January 2014, 18:00

Now that this year’s Oscar nominees have been announced, you might be wondering what it takes to be counted in that illustrious number. Many of you on this website have some interest in getting into the film industry. Some of you want to be stars and dazzle audiences with your performances, while others want to be acclaimed directors in the vein of Hitchcock or Scorsese. Take heart, aspiring actor/director/screenwriter, etc., for the February edition of the American Sociological Review will include scientifically-vetted guidance about how to increase the “Oscar-appeal” of your future endeavors. A group of sociologists from the University of California – Los Angeles researched “the economic effects of prizes with implications for the diversity of market positions, especially in cultural fields.” According to the researchers,

Many prizes have three notable features that together yield an emergent reward structure: (1) consumers treat prizes as judgment devices when making purchase decisions, (2) prizes introduce sharp discontinuities between winners and also-rans, and (3) appealing to prize juries requires costly sacrifices of mass audience appeal.

  They decided to test this theory by analyzing the Oscar-nominated film that came out between the years of 1985 and 2009. Over the course of the study, the researchers developed an algorithm that can measure a film’s “Oscar appeal.” According to the algorithm, the films with the highest Oscar appeal followed these rules, as summarized by Pacific Standard:

1. Stick to the genres of “drama, war, history, and biography.” Avoid: “horror, science fiction, action, and family.”

2. Plot points vary a bit, but try crafting the story around “political intrigue, disabilities, war crimes, and show business.” Best to avoid plot points like “animal attack, sword fight, and eaten alive.”

3. Release the movie near the end of the year. “This finding is consistent with the practice of Oscar-contending films having a qualifying run (i.e., a token theatrical release) around Christmas.”

4. Hand the project to the independent division of your enormous studio. “We find that the most advantageous type of distributor for attaining Oscar nominations is the ‘independent films’ subsidiary of a major studio (e.g., Sony Pictures Classics or Focus Features). These specialty divisions outperform mainstream divisions of major studios and true independent distributors.”

5. Go for the R rating. “This rating gives more artistic flexibility, which tends to be favored by prize voters,” the authors note.

6. Recruit directors with previous Oscar nominations. “In our analysis, prior nominations are statistically significant for directors but not for writers or actors.”

Sorry Pacific Rim, I don't think this is your year.

Sorry Pacific Rim, you didn’t stand a chance.

It is a bit sad to see that there is a limited amount of movie types that are most likely to win prestigious prizes. I know, your PG-13 space opera summer blockbuster rife with chase sequences and fight scenes should be worthy of the Academy’s praise, but the numbers say that’s highly unlikely. Still, even if you flout these findings and the recommendations that come with them, your film can still make an absurd amount of money, and isn’t that the greatest award of all?

Yes. Yes it is.

Via American Sociological Review and Pacific Standard

Written by

Dimitry is a seasoned researcher, a public media enthusiast, a lifelong gamer, and a fanatical technophile. While he holds degrees in political science, public policy, and legislative affairs from two of the nation’s finest universities, Dimitry is most proud of his Bachelor of Chiptune awarded by the chip-punk gods of Anamanaguchi. Additionally, Dimitry regularly spends far too much money on movies, video games, graphic novels, music, and the rest of his geeky passions. After a brief stint as a podcast host and a summer working with National Public Radio’s Intelligence Squared U.S., Dimitry is making his triumphant return to media as a member of the OneOfUs crew.
  • Lucy Six Morris

    I find my best cure for insomnia is almost any movie nominated for an oscar

  • Christopher Jaramillo

    And Joss Whedon responded to his Oscar snub last year by saying, “Oh well, I might as well jump into my cash bin and swim naked around it for a few hours. Preferably with Oscar winners serving me drinks because my name is Joss FuckMuthering Whedon”

  • Sean S

    so…. you’re not actually saying anything about the quality of the films nominated… good grounded films with dramatic qualities that have distributors who believe in them and spend the campaign dollars to support them will always be the products garnering awards attention in the fall and early january. and running a campaign for the film is expensive, so getting an award for the film is a win win, both for the artist and the money people who backed it up. there’s no conspiracy or evil plan, it’s about finding that middle ground between art and commerce, and when you’re working with talented artists, their work is going to get attention and then probably be praised. you’re article isn’t really even complete to be honest…

    • HeavyDii

      You realized I’m not the one who did the study, right?